Main Menu
Google Search
Google
Current GWH News
Global Warming Hoax News From Around the Web

World Climate Report

» A Classic Tale of Global Warming Alarmism

» More Evidence Against a Methane Time Bomb

» Agriculture: Tropical Cyclones are Welcome Visitors

» Sea Level Acceleration: Not so Fast

» Hansen Is Wrong

» Earth’s Carbon Sink Still Strong and Growing

» Wild Speculation on Climate and Polar Bears

» Illiteracy at NASA

» The Heat Was On—Before Urbanization and Greenhouse Gases

» What’s to Blame for the Rains on the Plains?

***
NewsBusters - Global Warming

» CNN's Blitzer: 'I Don't Remember' Biden's Law School Plagiarism

» CNN's Chetry: 'Please Tell Me It's Not Lipstick Again'

» MRC Report Asks: Why No Fairness Doctrine for PBS?

***
Science and Public Policy Institute

» Growth Rates of Old Versus Young Forest Trees

» Water Use Efficiency of Agricultural Species

» Tropical Trees

» Global Temperatures and Biospheric Productivity

» Rewriting Sunspot History

» Analysis of the Second Order Draft of the Working I Contribution to IPCC 5AR

» The Economics of Biofuels

» The Warming-Induced Evolution of Terrestrial Plants

» Medieval Warm Period in Southern Europe

» Effects of Elevated C02 on the Stomatal Conductance of Agricultural Crops

» Response of Various Marine Animals to Ocean Warming

» Medieval Warm Period in Central Europe

» Growth Response of Grassland Species to Elevated C02 When Water Stressed

» Effects of Increased C02 on Herbaceous Plant Pests

» Medieval Warm Period in Northern Europe

» Loblolly Pines Defy the Progressive Nitrogen Hypothesis

» Response of Crustaceans to Ocean Warming

» Energy Inefficiencies of Biofuels

» Response of Marine Plants to Changes in Temperature

» Biofuels: The Carbon Debt They Owe

» Medieval Warm Period in Japan

» Response of Corals to Ocean Acidification

» Interactive Effects of C02 and Water Stress on the Growth of Woody Plant Species

» Biofuels: Land and Water Concerns

» Medieval Warm Period in Upper North America

***
Climate Science: Roger Pielke Sr. Research Group

» Roger Pielke Sr. is now on Twitter!

» 2012 Climate Science Weblog in Review by Dallas Jean Staley – A Guest Post

» The Weblog Is Retiring

» Publication Of “Reply to “Comment On ‘Ocean Heat Content And Earth’s Radiation Imbalance. II. Relation To Climate Shifts’ ” by Nuccitelli Et Al. By Douglass and Knox 2012

» Q&A From A Group Of Retired NASA Personnel And Associates

» The Importance of Land Use/Land Practices On Climate – A Perspective From Jon Foley

» Interview With James Wynn In The English Department At Carnegie Mellon University

» University Of Alabama At Huntsville October 2012 Lower Tropospheric Temperature Analysis

» USA Election Day 2012

» New Paper “Climatic Variability Over Time Scales Spanning Nine Orders of Magnitude: Connecting Milankovitch Cycles With Hurst–Kolmogorov Dynamics” By Markonis And Koutsoyiannis

***


» ClimateBallers and the MM05 Simulations

» t-Statistics and the “Hockey Stick Index”

» What Nick Stokes Wouldn’t Show You

» Mike’s NYT trick

» The CEI and NR Reply Briefs

» The implications for climate sensitivity of AR5 forcing and heat uptake estimates

» Kevin O’Neill’s “Fraud” Allegations

» Black Tuesday of Climate Science

» Inventory of Hide-the-Decline

» Another Porky from Mann, Williams and Fontaine

***
Watts Up With That?

» Owen Paterson: Fight Against Climate Change ‘May Cause More Harm Than Global Warming’

» Baseless claim from WWF: Half of global wildlife lost, says new WWF report

» Breaking Russia’s energy stranglehold

» Is Bill McKibben @350 a liar, idiot, or both?

» Claim: Cause of California drought linked to climate change – not one mention of ENSO or El Niño

» Forget carbon footprints, the new alarmist sales pitch is carbon handprints

» The new ploy of climate activistim: attacking financial institutions

» Paper: Influence of solar cycles on climate change during the Maunder Minimum

» NY Climate Spin: Putting on a brave face

» Weekly Climate and Energy News Roundup #151

» Insurance companies not seeing effects from posited ‘climate change’ spawned weather disasters

» My answer to the “why didn’t Watts ask a question?” brouhaha

***
Global Warming News

» MICHAEL MANN’S LIBEL LAWSUIT, CONT’D

» OMB Should Uphold Proposed Rollback of 2014 Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) Targets

» Senate Finance Committee Hears Testimony on Energy Tax Reform

» EPA to Regulate CO2 Emissions from Aircraft

» Secretary of State John Kerry Explains the Greenhouse Effect

» Rising CO2 Concentrations: No Measureable Impact on Floods, Droughts, and Storms

» MIT Study: EPA “Carbon Pollution” Rule Will Not Incentivize Investment In Carbon Capture Technology

» Model Projections Too Hot Over 55-Year Period – Study

» EPA’s 52nd Takeover of State Regulatory Program Provides Perfect Segue to New Paper on Cooperative Federalism in the Obama Age

» EPA’s Staff Recommends Lower Ozone Standard, But it Doesn’t Matter, Because EPA Has No Say

***
Fox News - Climate Change Stories

***
Michelle Malkin - Enviro-Nitwits

» Obama fires up Air Force One, Marine One, huge motorcade to deliver climate change warning at UN

» Al Gore has lost so much weight that he makes a Prius look like a Chevy Suburban SUV

» Resolved: Al Gore’s next mansion should be constructed from Climate March trash

» Big crowd at ‘People’s Climate March’ makes futile attempt to fill in carbon footprints of Gore, DiCaprio

» There Will Be Blood II: Al Jazeera counter-sues Al Gore in battle royale for Big Oil money

***
DailyTech Michael Asher`s blog

» Will the Real Antarctica Please Stand Up?

» Global Warming May Decrease Hurricanes, Research Suggests

» Japanese Report Disputes Human Cause for Global Warming

» Sea Ice Ends Year at Same Level as 1979

» A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the (Climate) Forum

» Climate Report Downgrades Ice Loss; Media Reports Opposite

» Princeton Physicist Calls Global Warming Science "Mistaken"

» Defying Predictions, Sea Level Rise Begins to Slow

» Electric Car Sales in Freefall; Industry Risks Collapse

» Glaciers in Norway Growing Again

***
C3 - Climate Cycles Change

***
CATO - Global Warming

» Public Schooling: War without End

» India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi Visits America: Washington Should Recognize another Emerging Great Power

» The Economics of Blueberries, as Metaphor

» On Its One-Year Anniversary, ObamaCare Gets an 'F'

» Libertarians and the European Union: A Rejoinder to Petr Mach

» PM Modi's US Visit: India Has to Look Like a Superpower to Get US Investors interested Again

» Rand Paul: A Real Foreign-Policy Alternative

» The Unintended Consequences of the American Way of Science

» Republicans Shouldn't Stoke International Revolution

» Piecemeal Sanctions Won't Deter Russia

» Economists' Arguments against Obamacare Lawsuits Backfire

» Zombie Spending

» The Liberty to Leave

» When It Comes to Student Loans, It's All Political

» FIRE's Mounting Lawsuit Attacks Bringing Free Speech Back to College Campuses

» UN Climate Summit: The Dirty Little Secret about Global Warming Obama Doesn't Want You to Know

» Don't Constrain Energy Growth

» The War against ISIS: Moving Beyond Convenient Myths

» Mr. President, CO2 Is Not Pollution, It's the Elixir of Life

» Regime Uncertainty Weighs on Growth

» Transforming China from within: Chinese Students Head to American Universities

» Will America Ever Learn from Its Middle East Mistakes?

» The Long-Run Solution to an Economic Mess

» If Indians Aren’t Investing in India, Will Foreigners?

» Scotland Votes 'No': More Governments Should Follow the U.K.'s Example of Self-Determination

***
CanadaFreePress - Global Warming

» Owen Paterson: Fight Against Climate Change ‘May Cause More Harm Than Global Warming’

***
More Global Warming Hoax News Feeds

---
Since Exxon Hasn't Sent Us Our First Million Dollars Yet You're Welcome To Help Pay Our Bills Until They Do.









Headlines

»New paper unable to link 2013 extreme weather of droughts, heavy rain & storms to AGW
Dr. Roger Pielke Jr. 'the bottom line on this new NOAA special report: If you are attributing any ex ...
»Skeptical scientist challenges warmist scientist to public debate! Dr. Roy Spencer: ‘Hey Andy Dessler, Let’s Debate Live’
»Meteorologist Joe D’Aleo: Justin Gillis NYT and Politifacts get it wrong – Warmists say that temperature ‘pause’ claims are ‘Mostly False’
»Astronauts Who Helped Kickstart Environmental Movement Say Climate Change is ‘Bogus’
According to today's Sunday Times, Duke, who took pictures of Earth aboard an Apollo 16 missio ...
»NYT: Obama’s failure to advance ‘climate change’ policy due to ‘conservative opposition’
»Veteran Meteorologist Stops Watching The Weather Channel because it ‘swallowed the whole box of Kool-Aid & pushes the human-caused climate change agenda’
'TWC jumped into the climate change cauldron...mantra of pushing the 'green agenda.'
»Congrats Al Gore! His climate ‘Town Hall’ has garnered 38 views on YouTube in its first 12 days!
»Global warming stalls — but not demands for cash
Ezra Levant: China's 'happy to reduce their carbon emissions – for a price. And that price is $100 b ...
»‘Dreary climate summit was surely their saddest fiasco yet’
»NOAA: 1695 Low Max Records Broken or Tied From Sept 11 to Sept 20. One record broken by 25F


Date published: Mon, 29 Sep 2014 16:50:00 +0000
Details

»Hey Andy Dessler, Let’s Debate Live
Texas A&M Prof. Andrew Dessler has decided to campaign against skeptics with claims we believe ...
»Canadian Air Invades the Southeast U.S.: The Movie
One thing I don’t like about living in the southeast U.S. is the humidity. So, when the first ...
»Satellites Image Massive California Wildfire
The massive King Fire 60 miles east of Sacramento, CA was deliberately set on Sept. 14, and still re ...
»The Uninformed, Hypocritical, Emotionally-Driven People’s Climate March
While as many as 100,000 people gather in New York City tomorrow to march for the use of more unreli ...
»The Curious Case of Record August Ocean Temperatures
Several people have noted the apparent mis-match between the NCDC report of all-time record warmth o ...
»Are Record Ocean Surface Temperatures Due to Record Low Wind Speeds?
The fortuitous revelation of record warm sea surface temperatures in August, only days before Climat ...
»10 Ways To Tell Tuesday’s UN Climate Summit Isn’t About Climate
Next Tuesday’s UN climate conference in NYC (called Climate Summit 2014) is for politicians, celebri ...
»What if the Global Warming “Pause” was “Fast Forward” Instead?
I’d like to take you through a little thought experiment. We all know that global warming has been o ...
»Spectacular Aurora Across Scandinavia
The best photos from last night’s K=7 auroral displays are coming in from Scandinavia. Check t ...
»The Aurora Reached Arizona Last Night!
As predicted, the first of two coronal mass ejections (CMEs) from the sun produced some good aurora ...


Date published: Mon, 29 Sep 2014 14:33:38 +0000
Details

»Testing Blog Cross-Post 2
again
»Reconciling Conflicting Climate Claims
Cross-posted from Coyoteblog At Real Science, Steven Goddard claims this is the coolest summer on re ...
»Computer Models as “Evidence”
Cross-posted from Coyoteblog The BBC has decided not to every talk to climate skeptics again, in par ...
»Another Plea to Global Warming Alarmists on the Phrase “Climate Denier”
Cross-posted from Coyoteblog Stop calling me and other skeptics “climate deniers“.  No o ...
»My Thoughts on Steven Goddard and His Fabricated Temperature Data Claim
Cross-posted from Coyote Blog. Steven Goddard of the Real Science blog has a study that claims that ...
»The Thought Experiment That First Made Me A Climate Skeptic
Please check out my Forbes post today.  Here is how it begins: Last night, the accumulated years of ...
»Explaining the Flaw in Kevin Drum’s (and Apparently Science Magazine’s) Climate Chart
Cross-Posted from Coyoteblog I won’t repeat the analysis, you need to see it here.  Here is th ...
»If You Don’t Like People Saying That Climate Science is Absurd, Stop Publishing Absurd Un-Scientific Charts
Reprinted from Coyoteblog science a “myth”.  As is usual for global warming supporters, ...
»Update On My Climate Model (Spoiler: It’s Doing a Lot Better than the Pros)
Cross posted from Coyoteblog In this post, I want to discuss my just-for-fun model of global tempera ...
»Climate Goundhog Day
I posted something like this over at my other blog but I suppose I should post it here as well.  Fol ...


Date published: Tue, 16 Sep 2014 22:33:21 +0000
Details

»Leading Climate Scientist Defects: No Longer Believes in the ‘Consensus’
By James Delingpole - One of the world’s most eminent climate scientists – for several d ...
»Global Warming and Settled Science
By Andre Lofthus The AGW community would have you believe that the science in favor of AGW is settle ...
»The Tragedy of Earth Day
By Doug L. Hoffman - It is Earth Day today, a chance for all tree huggers, green activists and other ...
»Climate scientist’s emails are shielded from disclosure, Virginia Supreme Court says
By Debra Cassens Weiss - The Virginia Supreme Court has ruled that a climate scientist’s emails are ...
»Global Warming’s Upside-Down Narrative
By Bjorn Lomborg - When politicians around the world tell the story of global warming, they cast it ...


Date published: Thu, 08 May 2014 20:29:04 +0000
Details

»ClimateBallers and the MM05 Simulations
ClimateBallers are extremely suspicious of the MM05 simulation methodology, to say the least.  A rec ...
»t-Statistics and the “Hockey Stick Index”
In MM05,  we quantified the “hockeystick-ness” of a series as the difference between the ...
»What Nick Stokes Wouldn’t Show You
In MM05, we quantified the hockeystick-ness of simulated PC1s as the difference between the 1902-1980 mean (the “short centering” period of Mannian principal components) and the overall mean (1400-1980), divided by the standard deviation – a measure that we termed its “Hockey Stick Index (HSI)”.  In MM05 Figure 2, we showed histograms of the HSI […]
»Mike’s NYT trick
I’m not sure McIntyre knows what ‘splicing’ is.  To me it means cutting and joinin ...
»The CEI and NR Reply Briefs
Online here.  CEI     NR
»The implications for climate sensitivity of AR5 forcing and heat uptake estimates
A guest post by Nic Lewis When the Lewis & Crok report “A Sensitive Matter” about cl ...
»Kevin O’Neill’s “Fraud” Allegations
Over the past year or so, Mann’s “ClimateBall” defenders have taken an increasing ...
»Black Tuesday of Climate Science
Today I will review the timeline of the above WMO 1999 graph in the light of the ClimateGate (CG) le ...
»Inventory of Hide-the-Decline
In a recent post, I reported on the diagram in Jones 1998 (Science), which pushed hide-the-decline a ...
»Another Porky from Mann, Williams and Fontaine
Jean S has spotted a highly amusing entry in Mann’s CV. The entry yields yet another porky in ...


Date published: Tue, 30 Sep 2014 12:03:52 +0000
Details

»Growth Rates of Old Versus Young Forest Trees
The planting and preservation of forests has long been acknowledged to be an effective and environme ...
»Water Use Efficiency of Agricultural Species
In some cases, the water-use efficiency increases caused by atmospheric CO2 enrichment are spectacul ...
»Tropical Trees
Going back in time to the final few years of the 20th century, Schaffer et al. (1997) grew two mango ...
»Global Temperatures and Biospheric Productivity
Among the many climate-alarmist fears of CO2-induced global warming is the concern that the producti ...
»Rewriting Sunspot History
In 2006, when I first made the mistake of writing publicly of my doubts about the Party Line on manm ...
»Analysis of the Second Order Draft of the Working I Contribution to IPCC 5AR
This new review is unlike the previous analysis because it focuses not only on a statistical analysi ...
»The Economics of Biofuels
Aside from rejecting biofuel expansion and use for environmental reasons (see Biofuels (Land and Wat ...
»The Warming-Induced Evolution of Terrestrial Plants
One of the grandest of catastrophes that climate alarmists contend will result from CO2-induced glob ...
»Medieval Warm Period in Southern Europe
Was there really a global Medieval Warm Period? The IPCC used to acknowledge there was; but they hav ...
»Effects of Elevated C02 on the Stomatal Conductance of Agricultural Crops
As the air's CO2 content continues to rise, nearly all plants will respond by reducing their leaf st ...


Date published: Tue, 30 Sep 2014 12:27:13 +0000
Details

»‘Kill Climate Deniers’ – upcoming new theatre funded by the ACT Govt (Canberra)
I saw a ref to this at Don Aitkin’s blog – and a quick look in google found this ...
»Blowout in Australian budget deficit quickly forgotten in the media – should steel the Govt to plan a double dissolution election
Budget deficit soars to $48.5bn – The Govt can not take the steps required to balance the budg ...
»Many fatalities from eruption on Mt Ontake – what geophysical warning signs were there?
Early reports over the weekend like this from the BBC said [The question of no warning is harder to ...
»Shades of 19th Century railway gauges – brand new CSIRO ship can not plug into wharf electricity
The ABC reports – CSIRO’s new $120m Investigator can’t plug into Hobart shore powe ...
»“The Economist” could read what they said they day before
I was reading this 2012 article on India-China border disputes with useful map when I noticed their ...
»Spanish company comes downunder to the ACT for Australian PV solar subsidies
The GreenLeft ACT Govt has a “90 per cent target for the use of renewable energy (electricity) ...
»Fishing industry disquiet at South Australia State Labor Govt increasing areas of marine parks on back of Green claims
The Australian is reporting – Suicide warning as Labor locks up fisheries – full text pa ...
»South Australia adopts a 50% renewables target for 2025 – propped up by interstate coal fired generators
The SA State Govt elected with only 47% of the two party preferred vote due to the gerrymandered ele ...
»Australia should leave the UN – pull out of all UN treaties – save the money
Media reports the UN saying – “Coal has no future in the world’s energy mix ...
»Amazing that amid prosperity the New Zealand Government can not win half of the vote in general election
In a violence ridden world where many major economies are debt ridden and performing poorly – ...


Date published: Tue, 30 Sep 2014 08:23:37 +0000
Details
Latest Forum Posts
Posted by Anonymous
Search AGWunveiled to discover the two drivers tha[more ...]
08/18 07:00

Posted by Anonymous
[ REQUIRES ADMIN APPROVAL ]
07/28 02:48

Posted by Anonymous
Yes
07/25 01:42

Posted by Joel Carlson
What do all the green plants on earth need to prod[more ...]
07/17 12:10

Posted by Anonymous
http://cpubuilds.com offers some insight into glob[more ...]
06/15 13:46

Posted by Anonymous
Global warming - this is old news for everyone! I [more ...]
02/27 12:28

Posted by Anonymous
Interesting blog about Global Warming in space. Th[more ...]
02/22 09:27

Posted by Anonymous
I want to thank you for this wonderful blog. And I[more ...]
02/22 08:21

Posted by Anonymous
Interesting blog about climate and global warming.[more ...]
02/22 08:18

Posted by Anonymous
Interesting blog about climate and global warming.[more ...]
02/22 08:15

Relevant Sponsors

Donations
Any Amount helps support improvements





* or *


Advertise on this site

Road Gear

License Plate Frames
Support the Truth

Skeptic License Plate Frame
"SKEPTIC"

It's Natural License Plate Frame
"It`s Natural"

Liberty License Plate Frame
"Liberty"

* MORE *
Strong and durable metal license plate holder. Uses full color high resolution images. UV and Water Protection. Satisfaction Guaranteed
RSS Feeds
Our news can be syndicated by using these rss feeds.
rss1.0
rss2.0
rdf
Welcome
Username:

Password:


Remember me

[ ]
[ ]
Mobile Version
e107mobileYou can now visit us on your mobile phone! Simply goto http://GlobalWarmingHoax.com on your mobile phone or PDA to get started!

Debunking the CO2 Feedback Myth - by Leonard Weinstein, ScD
Admin, Thursday 14 May 2009 - 16:27:59 // comment: 1 //     printer friendly   //     Font Size - Increase / Decrease / Reset

The climate models used in the IPCC reports have made predictions of increases in global temperature of 2ºC to 6ºC over present levels by 2100. These predictions were based on assumptions regarding future CO2 levels and that water vapor would provide a large positive feedback effect. Dr. Weinstein (former NASA Senior Research Scientist) shows how both of these assumptions are either wrong or greatly exaggerated. No Longer Supported

Debunking the CO2 Positive Feedback Myth

Leonard Weinstein, ScD
May 11, 2009



Introduction:

The climate models used in the IPCC reports have made predictions of increases in global temperature of 2ºC to 6ºC over present levels by 2100. These predictions were based on two assumptions:

  1. The atmospheric CO2 level would go from 290ppm in about 1850 to at least 580ppm in 2100.
  2. The increase in CO2 would have both a direct greenhouse gas effect, and trigger a positive feedback effect. The result would be a small direct increase in temperature from the CO2 , but the increased temperature would also result in an increase in water evaporation. The water vapor is the major greenhouse gas in the atmosphere, and its increase would further increase temperature, resulting in a positive feedback until the process self-limited at a significantly higher level.

The predicted direct CO2 effect is estimated to be about 1C for the doubling of CO2 level. The present level of about 388ppm would have already caused about half of the direct rise, since the effect is nonlinear. The global temperature has apparently increased by about 0.7ºC in the last 150 years, which is slightly more than the estimated direct CO2 effect, but far short of the expected feedback imposed value. In addition, the temperature level up to about 1850 was significantly lower than typical levels during the last several thousand years. Much of the period between about 1200 to 1850 has in fact been called the “Little Ice Age”. The abnormal low temperature starting point for the change makes the distinction between natural temperature rise due to a recovery from the abnormally low temperature to the present difficult to separate from CO2 and positive feedback induced increases. The CO2 increase was small until about 1940, so the positive contribution from the CO2 is based on an even smaller maximum temperature increase (about 0.3ºC) and a shorter time. All of these facts indicate that calculations of any CO2 effects and positive feedback additions would have badly missed the actual present temperature if we did not already know it.

The proposed solution to the discrepancy by the IPCC is that sulfate gas and particulate pollution from burning fossil fuels, have caused atmospheric “Global Dimming”, which greatly inhibited the correct level of warming. While this cannot be totally refuted, it is not specifically supportable either. Since the need for a strong positive feedback is needed to support the projections for the temperature rise to 2100, the mechanism for such a rise is examined.


Proposed mechanism for glacial to interglacial temperature increases:

It is very likely that over the last several hundred thousand years, axial tilt and precession in the Earth’s orbital motion (Milankovitch cycles). have triggered the transitions from glacial conditions (lasting about 100,000 years) to the significantly warmer inter-glacial periods (lasting 10,000 to 20,000 years) During the glacial cycles massive spreads of glaciers and ocean ice formed over large regions at higher latitudes, and the average Earth temperature was significantly lower than for the inter-glacial periods. The increase of average Solar insolation that occurred due to these orbital variations is not nearly sufficient to directly explain the rapid increase in global temperature, and the rapid melting of much of that ice. The variation has to have been triggered more by the change in distribution of the Solar insolation on the surface. However, once the transition was triggered, it has been hypothesized that some forms of positive feedback amplified the increase in temperature.

The most likely form of the initial trigger was due to local increases in ocean temperature in higher latitudes causing some of the marginal ocean ice to melt, and the increased absorption from the increased ocean area resulting in additional ocean absorption of Solar energy. This positive feedback was probably limited due to the small level of direct increased warming. However, the increased area of ocean and slight increased temperature also caused the water vapor pressure to slightly increase. Since water vapor is a strong greenhouse gas, this led to further temperature increases, resulting in a strong positive feedback. The increasing ocean temperature eventually resulted in large amounts of CO2 to be released, since the solubility of the water to CO2 is lower at higher temperature, and the oceans hold the vast majority of ocean+air CO2 . It appears that the large increase in CO2 lagged the overall increasing surface temperature by about 800 years or so. It is then proposed by some that the increased greenhouse effect, due to the increasing CO2 level, supercharged the positive feedback by resulting in more heating. This additional heating then released more water vapor, and the positive feedback then took off until some mechanism stopped the process (possibly cloud formation).


Present conditions and additional heating:

The present total greenhouse effect from water vapor, CO2, Methane, and other greenhouse gases is estimated to make the surface 33ºC warmer than a surface without greenhouse gases. The direct contribution from the CO2 is estimated to be about 2ºC. All greenhouse gases other than water vapor are estimated to be about 3ºC. Why would a small amount of CO2 , or all other gases than water vapor cause more of a positive feedback for heating that that due to the water vapor itself? If there is positive feedback from just the initial forcing, it would not require CO2 to do something strange, the water vapor would do it (i.e., heating causes more water vapor, which causes more heating, etc.).

Also, since water vapor is the main greenhouse gas, positive feedback would make an unstable system unless there was some mechanism that halted runaway conditions. It is likely that increased cloud formation, or even a haze condition caused by the water vapor, would decrease the effective Solar insolation so that a stable temperature is reached. Any increase in any greenhouse gas with changes small compared to the existing total would be self-limited by the water vapor limiting properties. The fact of a self-limiting process for this type of feedback can be seen by the following example. During a hot summer, the total water vapor content is much higher than for a cold winter. If there were no self-limiting mechanism, this would result in a runaway condition, which is not observed.

There is one way the small direct temperature increase from the CO2 could trigger a positive feedback (of limited scope). That would be if the small direct increase were world wide, and significantly decreased total global ice cover on the oceans. The total yearly average of the extent of ocean ice has only been measured for a few decades, and even though it has recently decreased somewhat, the present net effect is that less than 0.3 percent of the Earth’s surface has been exposed to a lower albedo (and thus higher absorption of energy), and this is at locations of very low Solar insolation. Most of even this ice area change is probably due to the natural variation, but the net change of absorbed energy is not sufficient to make a significant difference even if most of it was due to the CO2 increase. In addition, the melted area is now decreasing as we go into a multi-year cooling period. Historical records indicate this slight variation is not unusual over several decadal cycles.


Conclusion:

Since water vapor is by far the largest greenhouse gas on the Earth, and since the Earth is mostly water covered, it is easy to see why the response of water to perturbations in the level and distribution of Solar insolation would be most important in the shift from glacial ages to interglacial periods. Reasonable arguments can be made for a strong positive feedback of water vapor to explain the rapid temperature increase during the transition. It is clear that such feedbacks are self-limiting, since the increase stops. However, the possible claim that the much smaller CO2 contribution, which even lags the sharp initial rise by many years, can then cause an even stronger positive feedback defies logic.

A recent significant increase of CO2, possibly with a large anthropogenic input, still results in a total less than 7% of the atmospheric greenhouse gas effect. Only about 1/3 of that is in the increase over the claimed "natural" levels. It is posited that this can somehow override the water vapor self-limiting mechanism by triggering a small increase in temperature to thus release more water vapor and supercharge a temperature rise to several times the direct effect of the CO2 itself. Since the self-limiting mechanism for the water vapor is present, this does not follow logically. Actual temperature changes have many drivers, but CO2 does not appear to be a significant driver at the levels or variations in levels present, and certainly can't have the amplifying effect claimed.

Click here for a brief Bio of Leonard Weinstein, ScD




Reprinted here with the permission of Leonard Weinstein, ScD


Share or Bookmark this Article Using:
| furl furl | reddit reddit | del.icio.us del.icio.us | magnoliacom magnoliacom | digg digg | newsvine newsvine | Stumble_it Stumble_it | Facebook Facebook | Google Google | Fark Fark | Sphere Sphere | Netscape Netscape | Technorati Technorati | Yahoo! Yahoo! | Add to Favorites and Additional Bookmarks: Share GlobalWarmingHoax.com - Where the Truth Heats Up





Latest Forum Posts


Threads: 2103 | Replies: 811 | Views: 4630449
Translate to: French German Italian Spanish Portuguese GTM_LAN_DUTCH Russian Chinese Arabic Korean English